Daddy's Dairy, located at 354 Washington St., finished in first with 51 percent of the 401 votes cast.
Daddy's recently celebrated the second anniversary of its Stoughton location.
Known for their extensive soft serve offerings - well over 100 different flavors - Daddy's also has dozens of flavors of hard ice cream, sundaes, ice cream cakes, chocolate dipped bananas and chocolate lollipops.
Daddy's is also the preferred ice cream shop of Adam Sandler when he films movies in Stoughton.
Crescent Ridge, while technically on the Sharon side of Bay Road, is right on the Stoughton line, and is also a favorite of many Stougthon Patch readers. Crescent Ridge came in second with 32 percent of the vote.
Dairy Queen and Hilliards finished third and fourth respectively, with a combined 13 percent of the vote.
This poll continued a “Best Of” series that allows readers to vote for their favorite businesses and places in Stoughton.
The poll opened Monday morning and closed Friday morning. Take a look at the full results here: Best Ice Cream/Frozen Yogurt in the Stoughton Area